Titans sign AP

This is disdain... useless.

What does fit have to do with it. How did Alvin Kamara and Austin Ekeler "fit" behind Mark Ingram and Melvin Gordon? It doesn't matter. Darrynton Evans was drafted for this, and if he was healthy, he'd be getting the bulk of the workload. Evans and McNichols are practically the same size and I would say McNichols is bulkier and has more power. At the bare minimum, he's available.

AP (not anymore) and Foreman don't have the breakaway speed to take one to the house. Do you really want the offense to rely on 2 and 3 yard gains with no upside? I watched AP last year, not good. Detroit was silly not to give Swift more carries. I'm all for brining them both in, but McNichols is the better of the 3 at this point and provides the most potential.

 

Oh and Sargent is a fit? Come on.

 

I agree...I think we roll with the cheap vets we have now..a younger vet FA next year and Henry's eventual replacement in the draft

 

Kamara is overrated IMO.

 

I'd take Kamara right about now

 

LOL

I want any RB to be at least 225ish ... 230 plus is better

dont like scatbacks

 

I mean.. 1,500 in 3 out of his 4 years. 1,300 in the 4th. 64 TDs. ProBowl each so far. You can argue overrated/underrated but he's effective and productive.

My point is, just because a RB doesn't "fit" the mold of their predecessor, doesn't mean they're not a good fit.

 

That's fine as your preference but you're really drastically minimizing the field and will miss out. I'm glad we started CJ2K over Landale White. Call me crazy.

 

A, that’s not what I said about McNichols, so not disdain.
B. It’s about which guy allows for the least changes in offensive scheme, especially with only 1 week to prepare for a tough team in LAR who by the way, may have the leagues best pass rush now and Tennessee has been pretty poor at blocking much lesser pass rush.

And who is this comment meant for?

 

A. I'm giving you an example of someone else on this board... Don't get defensive.
B. Exactly! The guys who's been actively a part of the offense would be the one that requires the least changes and he also happens to be our go to pass protector.

P.S. The comment is meant for the board in general. My original post was... "I don't get the Sargent love and McNichols disdain". You responded to that. I gave you an example of someone having disdain for McNichols and I'm again pointing out how if the argument is "fit", Sargent is a worse example.