Would Jeff Fisher cement HOF status if he coached the Titans to a Superbowl win?

The question I always ask myself is, would your average fan go to the hall of fame to see Jeff Fisher. and the answer is no. He's likeable, but he's not really Hall of Fame material. There's nothing famous about him. But a superbowl win I believe would instantly put Vince young into the Hall of Fame because Vince's star shines much brighter regardless of his numbers. I think he could be one of the few hall of famers who is stat resistant when it comes to the voting. Jeff Fisher is going need at least 2 superbowls, maybe more. His likeability helps, but he is not memorable.

 

very unlikely and same for Dungy. It's not the hall of the very good...

 

I was going to try to dispute this, but you are right. The Hall is elite particularly with coaches. Fisher would at least need 2 for serious consideration.

 

it seems like its a lot harder for coaches to make the hall, so i don' think one would do it.

 

Yet again this is a matter for internet research to see the 21 coaches who have made the hall of fame.

Marv Levy, George Allen, Bud Grant are there and none of them won a super bowl. Sid Gillman is there and he won an AFL title in 63. Hank stram is there with 2 super bowl appearances and one win but honestly any idiot could have won with the 69 chiefs a team laoded with HOF players.

Levy and Grant went to several super bowls but never won.

George Allen had a high percentage of playoff appearances but only made one super bowl and lost. Allen does get a lot of credit for the 63 bear defense that led them to a title that year.

If we had a nice run of winning seasons much like we did from 99-2003 and won a championship in one of those years i think Jeff fisher does get to the hall.

 

Brilliant! Don't cite the fact he has one of the highest winning percentages in league history cite his color.

Is Doug Williams in the hall? Dungy deserves the hall, he earned it.

 

Fisher isn't even worthy of coaching the Senior Bowl.