i didn't even realize a debate was going on in here. I think you pick Luck regardless, playbook and team is set up for him compared to a scrambling QB. I have no idea if Indy even has the coaching personal to play up to RG3's strengths.
well lets be fair Young's greatest problems were mental, not physical. We all saw how he could take over a game. Sadly he just had a melt down or whatever it was.
Cam Newton crumbled against the Titans...... and you know our defense was nothing special last year. I'm with Deuce on this one.
I think Cam has the tools to be successful but i do think he'll fall off this year. As for luck. He has a neckbeard.
The dude posted total of 4757 yards and 35 TD's. It's not that bold of a claim to say he is going to fall off a bit. I'd expect around 3100 yards passing (500 rushing) and 20 TD's. Hopefully he can cut down on the interception's a little bit.