Is Andrew Luck GM material?

Funny

Luck was already mediocre to begin with this year.

Kaepernick is legit.

Not sure what's funny about it considering it's true.

Only one you could make an argument for would be Cam because he's played more, but Kaepernick has been more impressive in his 9 starts than ANY of the guys you listed have been in their two year careers.

Kaepernick = Superbowl
Luck = Couch

Kaepernick = Less than 25 turnovers
Luck = Over 25 turnovers

Kaepernick = Sounds normal
Luck = Sounds and looks like a gorilla

Only thing I know for sure right now is that he is a better system QB than Alex Smith.

Kaep = 2nd coming of Vince Young (his idol).

Wait for the sophomore year and beyond folks... gonna be hilarious.

But VY was never anywhere as good as Kaepernick is right now.

You also said the same thing about Cam... but he ended up having a better passer rating and finishing with a better record on the year.

I don't know why you are hating so much on Kaepernick... I thought he'd be a joke coming out of college too. Clearly I was wrong though.

Cam kind of sucked this year.

And it's gonna take more than half a season of fluke play to convince me Kaepernick is better than the joke he looked like coming out of high school.

Cam threw more TDs and less INTs in 2012 than in 2011... and had a better passer rating and a better record.

He was literally better in every category except passing yards and rushing TDs.

......and wins


I actually don't think thats true, but I dont care to check and just want to say Cam sucks hard.