ELI5: Why is Luck Considered a great QB?

Not sure I'd take Carr over Luck. Carr looks very good, but he also has the best WR duo in the league right now imo (Cooper and Crabtree are beasts right now) and a FAR superior O-Line to Luck.

 

Luck will end his career with more interceptions than Favre

 

And everyone else will be blamed

 

WTF is your problem? He has Hilton with just over 1000 yards and his TE Doyle with 440 yards. You think he is loaded with receiving talent? Gore has 750 yards rushing. Yet they are 6-6 with what I think is far less talent than we have. So explain your complaint and your great observations to all of us that don't watch football.

 

TY Hilton is more talented than every single one of our wide outs, so STFU and stop acting like he has nothing but Tre McBrides on his roster.

Not to mention they spent a first round pick on Dorsett. Colts have tried to give the guy weapons, rest is on him.

 

So two guys have talent, and other teams (like us) know it but still can't stop them. Please enlighten us with your explanation.

 

That's easy, our D is garbage.

 

Perhaps we aren't very good either?

You are acting like this guy has dirt on his team, but arguably, have the best offensive talent in the division.

He is a turnover machine, isn't the most accurate QB in the world, and does not take care of his body. Why is that so loved around here?

He has a HoF RB that was brought in to help him, a two time Pro Bowl WR, a first round WR, and a couple of decent TEs.

 

Maybe some on here respect that the guy gives 100%, whether he is loaded with talent or not. He has managed to beat us every year, home and away. You can't acknowledge that he has some skill sets?

 

Of course he has some skills, and he is tough as hell.

Doesn't make you a great QB or worthy of the hype that man gets.