Eddie vs CJ

CJ. He is a game changer. Eddie was not.

 

EG = Mule
CJ = Race Horse

What you want too do determines which is best

 

your kidding right? I thought for sure an old timer like you could produce a better Eddie > CJ argument than that..

I could litter this thread with a bunch of CJ "lets see Eddie do that" highlights.

CJ is better, period. He blows Eddie away in every statistical category. He's even got more TD's through his first 3 seasons than Eddie had through his first FOUR.

Eddie was NEVER considered the best runningback in the league, CJ was the best.

Please man, lets see Eddie run for 2000 yards in 1 season, and not need 700 carries to get there.

A lot of you old fans size Eddie so much but in all honesty hes one of the most overrated runningbacks of this decade, and I watched both play. He was a SOLID power runningback, he had heart and leadership, but hes not a hall of famer, and hes no where near the game changer CJ is.

 

how many PO games have the Titans won with such an awsome game changer?

You must not be familiar at all with 97-03 Oilers/Titans. Those teams would completly dominate and crush the opposition's will, and still need an Col. Klank FG to pull out the win thanks to fish face.

I remember a game against the Giants in Nashville where Titan D held Thunder & Lighting, supposedly the best RB combo in the game, to like 17 yards on 20 carries. Still only beat them like 17-13 or something. Gotta keep it close even when you can put them away early

 

I picked Chris Johnson because I think Chris Johnson has Hall of Fame potential. What hes shown so far... you can't knock him.

 

he had a 'diva' moment in the biggest game hes played in as a Titan.

I'll knock that every time

 

1 less than Barry Sanders.

Good argument

 

Oh, and the talent on the 97-03 Oilers/Titans is comparable to the Talent to the 2008-2010 Titans?

Sounds pretty biased to me..

We can play the "How many times" game all day, and you can act like I've forgotten who Eddie George was. I haven't, I remember his stiff arms for 0 yard gains, I remember him plowing through tacklers for a hard earned yard or 2, and I remember his pregame huddle chants that apparently make him a better runningback for some strange reason...

Your argument is so shallow its not even funny. CJ isn't "built like a runningback should be"??? What kind of BS is that? Who cares as long as the dude is getting yards? Eddie WAS built like a runningback "should be" and he only rushed for 4 yards per carry TWICE in his career.

Who are you to say CJ has never worn down a defense? Have you suited up against him in your life?

What you call wearing down a defense is apparently rushing for 2.5 ypc and getting 35 carries of that crap because Fisher doesn't know what hes doing. What I call wearing down a defense is watching 11 grown men chase 1 small "not built like a runningback should be" man for 4 quarters until they can't help but watch him break an 80 yard home run because no one has any gas left to catch him.

Eddie's miniscule success was the biggest product of Fisherball this world will ever see.