Rating the oilers/titans 1st rd picks...

I'm accusing him of missing multiple tackles a year with lame shoulder attempts. The same type of attempt you just blasted Pacman for. Are you saying you haven't noticed?

 

No I don't... No way Jason Taylor is HOF bound (according to your scale) and Isaac Bruce is only near.

Here's my grading scale:
A - Darren Woodson-Darrell Green-Brett Favre--2nd level elite

B+ - Aeneas Williams-Ken Anderson-Terrell Davis--near HOF..

NA - Too early to tell

95-Mcnair--B-

96-Eddie--B+

97-K holmes--D

98-K dyson--D

99-kearse--B

2000-k bulluck--B+

2002- haynesworth--C

2003-woolfolk--NA

2005-pacman--NA

2006-v young--NA

 

How does Woolfolk get an NA? It's been three years. Haven't you seen enough?

:flush:

 

You're right, but if we had picked Darren Howard, we coulda had a heckuva pass rush

But then experts thought Howard was too small to succeed (they also said that about Dwight Freeney almost 10 years later)...

One day, 53 will be recognized by his peers, and the "fans" who pick the Pro Bowl every year and the experts who select OLB to the All-Pro team cuz they did great in their last 4 games (Shawne Merriman??????!?!?!?) will eat their heart out...

 

OK I'll give him a D :winker:

 

I'd say anything more than 1 year deserves a grade.

 

all players one time or another have lame tackle attempts. last year was a wash for everybody I say because the D was ALWAYS on the field. Since you're so versed in our game-by-game, play-by-play for all 16 games last year, you should know this...

 

Obviously, but Bulluck has done it on multiple occasions and I'm not the one who gave Pacman a D while singling out a missed takle.

 

Oh OK, so Keith Bulluck is overrated because of the occasional lame tackle attempt?

And FTR, I wasn't the one who graded Pacman a D

 

I never said that. I was asking for clarification from RollTide since he seems to have a double standard.

Feel free to re-read the thread, and thanks for jumping in.