My Heath Shular Syndrome theory

I at least meant a RB! LOL!
That's a DB!
:ha:
point taken.

Still, doesn't anybody worry about a draft day nightmare if Cutler sails?
Then what? I'm not going to push the moot button but I think they would make M.L. the "fit" and draft him at #3 as opposed to moving down and anglin' for Cutler. There is the Chow factor.

 

I just went up there and looked at that post...
That was really stupid on my part.

It looks like a big neon sign flashing "I'm a %$#&^@! MORON"
that's good stuff...:lol3:

 

I don't think there is a "better fit". It's just a question of who is better...

 

how much pull will he have is the question? Not much IMO. He had an offense that couldn't push their way out of a wet paper bag.

What past OC does Chow remind you of?

 

there could also be the "Kyle Boller and JP Losman Syndrome" while talking about cutler.

made a bad team decent. people say he never had great stats because he had inferior talent around him. had all the physical tools, but was mentally inconsistent. poor footwork.

 

?

 

If your argument is that a QB will look better on a more talented team, then clearly I agree. But obviously that won't affect our pick.

As for Shuler, who is to say he wasn't just a bust? As mentioned elsewhere, tons of top college QBs from top teams don't do squat in the NFL.

Look, if we're picking at #3 we probably aren't going to be a great team anyway. I don't think there is much to "fit". Any QB we get will have the offense adjusted to fit his strengths.

 

I totally agree with your earlier post that we shouldn't take a guy like Lienart for fit. We should always take the best. The waters get a little more murky when looking at a guy like Young who is more of a running QB but the bottom line is if Leinart, Cutler and Young are all sitting there at #3 the one we should take (if we take any of them) is the one we really think is the best NFL QB.
I also agree that a guy like Shuler was simply a bust. Few of these high QB draft picks find a home on another NFL team even as solid backups after they bust for their original teams. That indicates to me they never had it to begin with.