Marino or Kelly?

It’s public

and I now question everything he posts unless he adds explanation for that nonsense.

 

This has to be a troll job. No one really thinks w/l against each other’s team is any kind of a deciding factor at all.
Cherry picking 3 categories of passing stats and saying they’re near identical, them saying because of that the stats are a wash, is just ridiculous.
Why would anyone consider the extra 25k yards or 175 TD passing when their comp % is close to the same?

 

Head to head is not really head to head. That’s Marino vs the Bills, one of the greatest all around teams ever and Kelly vs the dolphins, not the same story of greatness.
The H2H record is 100% worthless in the comparison of the 2.

While you’re looking into all the analytics and everything, I’m sure the question must have popped into your mind why Marino had 3000 more att. Not only was his career longer but he never had Thurman Thomas or even Greg Bell. The best he had was Kareem Abdul Jabbar, most people don’t even know him outside of the same name Basketball player.

We can also argue WR. Reed is a HoF, Kelly also had Lofton for a short window. Marino had some solid guys but outside of Fryar, who only had a couple seasons in MIA, he didn’t get HoFers.

 

This was only formality anyway, and the one, while not a good explanation, has reasoned to himself Kelly was better.
That’s fine, I’d assume, even counting bills fans, the national voting average of a Marino vs Kelly poll would be close to 25:1 in favor of Marino.

Let’s MSM the numbers. 96% believe marino. If applied nationally to 350 mil people, only 13 mil would believe Kelly is better, and I’m confertable thinking that is close to the bills fan base plus legit conspiracy weirdos/druggies.