Marino or Kelly?

Discussion in 'Tennessee Titans and NFL Talk' started by HurrayTitans!, Jun 15, 2022.

?
  1. Dan Marino

  2. Jim Kelly

Results are only viewable after voting.
  1. Tewa Titan

    Tewa Titan Starter

    1,627
    434
    289
    I think any skill position players from back in the day would feast on the league in it's current state, outside maybe some defenders like DL,LBs, and possibly RB.
     
    • High Five High Five x 1
    • Cheers Cheers x 1
  2. The Hammer

    The Hammer Ace Degenerate

    50,144
    15,573
    1,239
    A lot of DBs would have trouble today. That is the biggest difference, and what makes being a QB a lot easier. They really tightened up what you can do to a WR down field.

    Going further back, Dick "Night Train" Lane used to tackle by the head.

    A lot of old OL would have trouble today because of changes to protect defensive players. Those Shannehan Broncos teams were notorious for those blocks.


     
  3. GoT

    GoT Strength and Honor

    63,741
    18,183
    1,509
    "if you have a thoroughbred you let them go, you let them play" - jimmyjohnson
     
  4. Broken Arrow

    Broken Arrow Just a Fan....

    4,072
    1,144
    489
    You are 100 percent correct
     
  5. Big Time Titan

    Big Time Titan Big Time Titan

    6,790
    2,088
    719
    Kelly was good and had a much better supporting cast. Marino had the arm accuracy and toughness, his teams just weren’t as good as the ones the bills had.

    Had Marino left Miami he would have certainly won a super bowl.
     
    • Cheers Cheers x 1
  6. MrBean

    MrBean Master of Not Much

    1,394
    649
    519
    Marino was never the GOAT.

    it went from Montana to Brady.
     
    • Cheers Cheers x 1
  7. Hormesis

    Hormesis Pro Bowler

    4,389
    1,381
    539
    Put Marino on Montana teams, better result imo. Montana was awesome too, but as far as passing is concerned, Marino be handing Joe his jockstrap.
     
  8. GoT

    GoT Strength and Honor

    63,741
    18,183
    1,509
    LOL... I was talking as a QB

    clearly Montana won more. And what he did in KC, although no championships there, was amazing.

    and yes Montana GOAT prior to Marino

    before Montana I would say Namath ( without looking things up ) and before Namath Unitas ( based purely on reputation as I never saw him play except as an old man if I saw him at all )

    I guess I am taking playing QB as separate from being on a winning team.


    Zero doubt in my mind that T17 best QB titans have had not named McNair since moving from Cowtown. But the vy nut swingers would pathetically point out that clowns W% as meaning something other than he had a good defense for a few years

    And I will give credit to old man manning handing the rock to the RB and winning a ring... that is solid QB play... if you have the defense you can win championships being a game manager as a QB. But that dont make him GOAT IMO
     
    #18 GoT, Jun 19, 2022
    Last edited: Jun 19, 2022
  9. Ontario Titan

    Ontario Titan Pro Bowler

    12,758
    3,444
    789
    Tom Brady vs. NFL's Greatest Quarterbacks

    Montana vs Brady

    Why Montana is better: Unlike almost any other quarterback in NFL history, Joe Montana actually embraced the bright lights of the postseason. In fact, he was better by a full three points in passer rating in the postseason (95.6) than the regular season (92.3).

    He is also the Super Bowl leader in passer rating and set the record for single-season passer rating in 1989 (only to have his record broken five years later by Steve Young).

    Why Brady is better: Both Brady and Montana had good defenses when they won Super Bowls, but Brady enjoyed his Super success without the blessing of top-quality receiving talent. Brady has also been a far more efficient passer on his career, a 96.4 career passer rating to Montana's 92.3.

    That being said, it's far easier to be more efficient these days than it was when Montana was torching defenses in the '80s.

    Who's better?: Joe Montana
     
  10. Ontario Titan

    Ontario Titan Pro Bowler

    12,758
    3,444
    789
    Marino vs Brady
    Why Marino is better: Dan Marino was putting up big numbers before big numbers became pedestrian. His record of 48 touchdown passes in a single season, set back in 1984, stood until 2004.

    Marino was ahead of his time and did it when the rules didn't so heavily favor the offenses. Brady is just now getting his taste of carrying the team to victory, but Marino did it for a long period of his career.

    Why Brady is better: As prolific as Marino was as a passer in the regular season, Brady has been more efficient when the stakes are higher. Brady's postseason passer rating of 87.6 may be tame by his lofty standards, but it's still better than Marino's 77.1.

    Just like Marino can't take the blame for having never won a Super Bowl, Brady wasn't the only reason the Patriots won three Super Bowls in four years, or that they've been to five in 11 years.

    Who's better?: Tom Brady
     
  • Welcome to goTitans.com

    Established in 2000, goTitans.com is the place for Tennessee Titans fans to talk Titans. Our roots go back to the Tennessee Oilers Fan Page in 1997 and we currently have 4,000 diehard members with 1.5 million messages. To find out about advertising opportunities, contact TitanJeff.
  • The Tip Jar

    For those of you interested in helping the cause, we offer The Tip Jar. For $2 a month, you can become a subscriber and enjoy goTitans.com without ads.

    Hit the Tip Jar