I've seen some stupid lists before but this might just take the cake

he's not factoring in the fact that Vick hasn't seen NFL action in 2 years

 

Don Banks (author of that list) looks like the Uncle on Napoleon Dynamite.

I dont trust him.

 

he looked right tonight

 

lol @ Vince should be higher than Vick.


...why?

 

Ahh you've got to love homers!!

Vince Young Career Passer Rating:

68.8

Michael Vick Career Passer Rating:

75.7

Let's compare their last full seasons.

Vince Young

Passing Yards: 2546
Passing TDs: 9
%: 62.3
Rushing Yards: 395
Rushing TDs: 3
Interceptions: 17
Fumbles: 5
Rating: 71.1

Michael Vick

Passing Yards: 2474
Passing TDs: 20
%: 52.6
Rushing Yards: 1,039
Rushing TDs: 2
Interceptions: 13
Fumbles: 4
Rating: 75.7


Percentages are screwed because Vince throws more than 5 yard passes. But He more than doubled him in touchdowns, and had less interceptions.
He also more than doubled him in rushing yards.


No contest. While Vick sucks as a QB, he's still better than Vince by a long shot. Vick was actually wanted by several teams after prison. Vince isn't wanted by several teams as we speak.

 

I'd be willing to put Vince above Vick... The dude's been crummy over the last two years, but at least he's actually still been in the NFL.

I could realistically see Vick turning out to do well this year, and at that point I'd be willing to concede him a higher position than Vince - but I could just as realistically see him bombing out when his athletic ability can't carry him any more.

 

Sorgi should be Lower, so should Troy Smith, Henne, and Simms.

I like the placement of Volek, Rosenfels. and Seneca Wallace though.

 

Seeing as Vince has done just that..