I have not yet seen Krampus. But between the other two it's an easy choice for me. While I enjoyed some of the Lepreachaun movies for what they were, that first Candyman scared the s*** out of me when I was a kid.
Two straight up movie villains vs a traditional villain, who for some reason only now is featured in a film.. Krampus has been terrifying Bavarian children for centuries.. Gotta go with the Anti-Santa
Krampus was one of the best movies last year. Candyman is direct to video ****. Leprechaun is softcore porn/comedy
Actually Candyman was something a bit more relevant than direct-to-video trash. Based off of a famous Clive Barker story - during the peak of the Clive Barker craze. One of the first post blaxploitation era horror films to somewhat center around the black community.. Set in the infamous Cabrini Green projects of Chicago. It was a theatrical release that had a pretty decent bit of national promo. Formalized Tony Todd as a popular horror actor.. etc.