Caleb Farley has herniated disk

It's doable. First team I looked at. By the "no second contract" metric, Chandler Jones was a bad pick. I'm basing the no picks as losses, but it really depends on who they traded for. Given that they've made some crappy trades (i.e. Mohamed Sanu), I'm going with busts.

This would be fun do with with different teams and calculate hull hit vs bust rates.

 

Facts fans don't want to accept:
1. You can be a good first-round pick even if you're not a pro bowler.
2. You can be a good first-round pick even if you don't get a second contract with original team.
3. There is a lot more to a GM's job and team's success than first-round draft picks.
4. There is a lot more to a GM's job and team's success than just the draft.
5. No GM or team is perfect in the draft.
6. No GM or team is perfect in free agency.
7. Although not perfect, JRob has been good overall in the draft and phenomenal with late-round picks and free agents.

 

Really didn't get them passing up Darrisaw after he fell into their lap for Farley. Jrob really has blown some of these obvious picks. Sure would be nice to plug Darrisaw into Dennis Daley's spot right now...

Alex Leatherwood was still the goofiest pick of that draft though lmao

 

JRob just loves those high risk high reward picks. Farley did play great that season for VT they had the tape on. Just injuries have killed the young man. I'm not going to knock on him because he's not getting hurt in purpose. Just don't take him in the first round.

 

I understand your list but you really can't put a x on Derrick Morgan. He was not flashy but he played 9 years and had 44.5 sacks. That's not a miss.

 

played 9 years and got right at a SAC a month... THAT right there is a bit of a problem

 

He's utterly forgettable

 

If you let your 1st rounder leave after rookie contract that is a bust pick, don't care what they do on other teams..the point is they aren't here..you don't spend first pick being satisfied with 3 years