PFFing Jon Robinson

Fun read


Good job

 

Good read. Tough to really judge JRobs position without having graded enough other GM’s to know what the avg for a GM would be.

I also agree on the scale being too small per player which lead to a little inconsistency on the grading to me. Not awful by any means, but the Tajae ranking seems high in comparison to other WR but then Austin Johnson seems low because the crap below him is so closely ranked to him.

 

Also, if you're going rank a drafted player highly because he was pro bowl his rookie year, you really can't say "too early to tell" for other rookies who haven't done anything. That suggests bias for positive performance only.

 

I think it's innacurate because you can't measure isaiah wilson with simply a -2. He deserves like a -4

 

Who was pro bowl their rookie year?

 

The grading is based on how PFF grades players lol he didn’t make this up himself.

 

I get it and it took some time for you to rank each move, I like the read. I dont particularly like PFF and their rankings. I know in another thread it was discussed about the -2 to 2 parts but (at least without paying) there really isnt a break down by position of how they grade each play on what they call a mistake vs. a good play for example.

Football just has so much subjective pieces and so much individual play that relies on the efforts (or talent) of other players. GM included.