Game Day Thread Titans @ Eagles GDT

Nobody cares about the success of his drive against a vanilla defense sitting most of its starters. His passes have no zip, he locks onto one guy, he delivers balls late and misses opportunities for YAC or completions altogether like the sideline throw to Jennings . People would probably be making less of a deal if Tannehill didn't look much better in every way. Again, it's not the numbers, it's the arm strength, accuracy, pocket poise, decisiveness , and general consistency with his delivery in contrast to what we saw from Mariota on Thursday and the previous two years

 

I agree with this for the most part. Mary is still lobbing passes and throwing late and he has got to stop that chit.

 

Both?

 

Seen plenty of Mariota performances where this analysis is just wrong. His issues are consistency and injuries. He does not alway lock on to receivers, he has demonstrated pocket presence often, and he has plenty of arm to succeed in the league.

 

He's just as inconsistent in year 5 as his rookie year. This is his last year here.

 

"Forum Rules

7. Agree to disagree. Everyone's opinion counts, is valued, and should be respected. If you can't respect someone's point of view -- ignore it! Personally attacking another poster by name-calling will not be tolerated. You may call someone's comments "stupid" without calling the person who made the post "stupid". Take any negative personal stuff to a private message or e-mail."

Also, you can't win a debate by calling people names, only with better logic and reason. Calling Mariota's performance poor is a stretch. Trying to compare him to Tannehill given the same one series is rational, but this is also preseason week 1. Most of our offense wasn't playing and no one is game planning anything so how Mariota or Tanny did doesn't mean anything in terms of a QB controversy/competition.

Nice to see Tanny play well with some playing time. Let's see how everyone does over the next 3 weeks!

 

Please post this. Who said this based off one game where he threw 124 yards?

But who cares. If someone loves Mariota, why do you care so much about it that you need to insult them just because they disagree with you. Can you make an argument without personal attacks?

 

That's awesome you are a professional at evaluating QB's in different systems and styles. Fantastic! Who will be better...Tom Brady or Kyler Murray? Which of the young qb's (under 25) will be voted into the Hall of Fame? Who is winning Rookie of the Year? Please list this season's All-Pro players.

 

It's funny THill, at one time starter, goes up against 2's and 3's defensively and on top of it vanilla preseason defense and he should start? If he had the goods he'd still be in Miami. Hell Logan threw 2 TDs start him. Fantasy football has officially f***Ed with people's minds too stat driven now days.

 

Could be. I personally won’t say he is inconsistent in year five after the drive I saw from him. Think I will wait for a bit more evidence. Last year is hardly an indicator given his injuries. We will see if he puts it together this year