Which would make you feel worse?

we don't have a qb on the roster that will win us a super bowl, especially if we don't sign haynesworth.

 

we had one in KFC this year

this team needs a prototypical drop back passer who can hit his mark and VY has not shown anything that makes ME feel as if he can CONSISTENTLY deliver on the field ...

... and then we can get into the whole immaturity issue if we want to

 

we had a qb who managed to score more than 15 points per game, which was enough to win because had a top flight defense.

without haynesworth do you think we'll be able to win like that?

let's face it, whoever plays qb for this team is almost irrelevant. all he has to do is not fumble while handing the ball off and score two touchdowns and a field goal to win.

 

Quite a bit more, actually...we averaged 23 points a game last season, which is absolutely substantial. Do I think we could win scoring an average of 23 points per game without Haynesworth? Absolutely. Do I want to see Haynesworth go? Not at all, I just think he's going to cost more money then any one NON POINT SCORING player is worth. He's a vital cog in our wheel, absolutely, but he isn't the only reason we were successful on D either

 

I agree with you here, but I wouldn't say it would be a setback big enough to drop us out of the 'top tier' classification of defense. And bear in mind, the line was the key area of Schwartz's scheme...Haynesworths loss could be compensated to dome degree by blitzing some linebackers (where we're pretty stacked, btw) down field to get pressure from other spots...

 

I've been suspecting this for some time, but now I'm convinced... you're just a retread of "Mr. E".

The idea that those of us on here, who are all pretty huge Titans fans (I mean, we spend time on a website forum discussing the team, obviously, we care) would be pissed at our team going to the Superbowl, is ridiculous. The idea that we would prefer a losing season is ridiculous. I don't care if we trade for Peyton Manning and he gets us to the superbowl. I hate him, but I'd be happy. The idea that Vince Young may never be a successful NFL QB is no nearly as outlandish. Yes, some people have negative opinions of him, but it's silly to argue that the fans of this TEAM would care more about him than how the team does on the field. Honestly, I really don't care about Vince Young, unless he helps or hurts this team. If he helps us win, I'm all for him, and I honestly wish that he would break out and show some progress and be our leader. However, I'm not expecting that. And if he isn't capable of taking those steps, and we spend the next three years in mediocrity while paying him millions, I'll be pissed.

Many people express many valid opinions on here that I either don't like or don't agree with. Yours is simply not a rational opinion, and is frankly an insult to the fans on this board. I'm hoping you get enough neg reps to stick you in the smack forum where you belong.