Trent Dilfers QB Rankings by Group

Trent Dilfer may be retarded, but that's exactly where VY belongs.

 

and this is why I believe we keep 3 QBs

 

how does alex smith end up in the "not enough evidence" category, but VY is in the "rehab project"?

435 completions 800 attempts 54.4% 4,679 yards 19 tds 31 ints
444 completions 775 attempts 57.3% 4,964 yards 22 tds 32 ints

can you tell who's who?

 

Looks about right to me. It seems like Carson Palmer is always 'KNOCKING AT THE DOOR', but being on a lousy team hurts him (literally).

 

Trent Dilfer is a douche he has Manning ahead of Brady And then he has ELi in the Star category Eli is average at best. People don't realize before the Giants went on the hot streak to the Super Bowl there were a lot of people calling him a bust.

 

As he should be.

Yeah, people used to talk, but then he pulled through for his team and WON the Superbowl. Brady got clobbered that game. Man-crush on Brady?

 

Looks pretty accurate. Remember, these are not based on fantasy stats.

 

I freakin hate hate hate Brady but until Manning wins three super bowls, your statement is moot.

No, just like Vince's second season with the Titans, the Giants more or less carried Manning through that SB. All Eli had to do was say it with me...manage the game.
Are you really that clueless, Psy?

I don't think Vince should be put with Carr and Harrington...yet.
However, one or two more seasons of playing like he has been and it will be a more accurate assessment. He's not there yet, but well on his way.