Well I just got back from watching the new Star Trek and I loved it. I will give it a few days before I start talking about what made me like it so much. I definitely recommend!
I also really liked it although it certainly had some problems. I really want to see it again to see if the plot holds up or not. I think if you look at things from the villains perspective it makes sense but I really need to watch it again since the plot is glanced over for more action sequences.. But an obvious example of some problems I had... spoilers below.... Cold fusion stops a volcano? Please. Don't they know cold fusion is still ****ing hot? And so they hide a spaceship in the ocean to hide it from a primitive culture... Uh, why not just hide in space? OH yeah I know, cause they wanted a shot of the Enterprise lifting up out of water.
Because that little shuttle wouldn't have held up in the atmosphere would be my guess....or they wanted a really cool shot.