Those are all good games. But Skyrim had me absolutely hooked, which is really rare for me these days. Like all I ever wanted to do was play it lol. It completely took over my life for a few months. Arkham Asylum I really liked but I started to get tired of it toward the end. Kinda couldn't wait for it to end. Same with Borderlands. Now, Arkham City I LOVED and would probably put it in my top 5 of that generation. Heavy Rain is definitely up there in the top 5 for me as well. But none of them can touch Skyrim for my money. It was just so deep and it felt like an actual universe much more than any other game I've ever played.