Most Indispensable Player

I voted Manning not only because of what he does, but because of his durability and longevity. He hasn't missed a start in his career (even after that horrific blow he took against Washington a while back, even I admired that) and he's been around for a while.
The Colts aren't used to life without Peyton, if he's out for a length of time they'll start to see exactly how much he means to them. Kinda like us with Eddie George (bear with me), when we made the switch to Chris Brown we missed Eddie's short-yardage value. Take out a player like Peyton and, though Sorgi can succeed when playing reliever, soon people will see just how much Peyton does that few others can.

...That being said, I hate him lots. Superbowl MVP my rear end...