McNabb to Redskins

Ok.

I'll trump your nothings with this: Who has the most recent playoff win? Shanahan.

 

Gotcha.

I disagree though particularly about Reggie. I think he's pretty good. He's just not a true running back, he's a hybrid RB/WR. But I think his role is pretty important for the Saints style. I think they would be noticeably worse without him, unless they acquire a replacement with his unique skill set.



Maybe you guys are right. I had forgotten about Portis's concussion. I still think Portis, LJ, Willie Parker is an upgrade over Portis, Betts, whoever. I think Parker could surprise, only 98 carries last year, only 29, and only 2 years removed from 1300. I wouldn't bet on him turning it around, I just "could" see it happen and it wouldn't shock me.

They just need to draft a OT. And I thought they could trade Campbell but they will just rescind his offer and he will sign wherever.

If they trade AH they are CRAZY unless they could get a very good O-line or a 1st rounder. I know the popular opinion is he will suck until a contract year, but I say if they are in playoff contention he gets serious at the end of the season, I think he'll play hard for a potential ring.

 

Not really saying much. He is 1 - 5 in his last 6.

 

I don't think he'd be any different with Vince Young or Drew Brees to be honest.

 

No, the team killer in their SB appearance was ANDY REID . Watch that moron standing there perusing the Subway take-out menu while the clock ticks away... they had plenty of time to win that game. He should have been fired before he left the stadium.

 

Honestly, this shouldn't be such a big debate.

Shanahan > Zorn
McNabb > Campbell
LJ & Parker > Betts
'10 Skins > '09 Skins

The Redskins are alot better now. But that's what it looks like every year and look what happens. Shanahan is a legit coach, alot better than Zorn. He has so much more exp. than Zorn. McNabb is way better than Campbell. LJ+Parker are better than Betts. It's not that hard guys.

 

Im no GM but you probobly shouldnt trade your pro bowl qb to a team within your division!! If football is a business, you just gave your competitor some competitive advantage over you! IMO McNabb has won games in the NFL, and kolb doesnt have much experience and in the nfl its "What have you done for me lately". As for philly fans, they will never be happy IMO. I won't feel sorry for them if they dont win too many games this year because they did it to themselves.

 

Willie Parker is done. If anyone is counting on him, well don't.

 

This is very true. Coaching blew that one.

 

Very true, stupid move on Philly's part. Andy Reid blew this one big time, Kolb ain't nothing special and isn't half as good as Donovan and Philly will rue the day they shipped him to DC.

I won't feel sorry for them at all. They screwed themselves on this one.