What are you talking about? Starting years? You mean we don't count the years henry was a no show? We only count his best seasons? If the guy is sitting on the bench it's his damn fault. Why would such a stud ever be on the bench? Henry was a starter in the first year mcgahee played. He sucked and lost his job. That year playing with the same offensive line henry averaged 3.5ypc while mcgahee averaged 4.0. As i said in a previous post mcgahee has only missed 2 games in the last 3 years to injury while henry missed 10 plus 4 more for suspension. That doesn't matter? It doesn't matter that while henry was a no show pos not even cracking 400 yards for 2 straight years mcgahee was getting well over 1000? Mcgahee has averaged 1122 yards each year he played while henry averaged 899. That's the fair comparison. Every poster that is kissing henry's butt now were bashing him after the 2005 season. Does 2005 not count?