Manning G.O.A.T.?

What's all this talk about manning buying the titans....?

I keep hearing the same thing about him joining UT's coaching staff.....

 

Brady better








thanks for coming out

 

lol Yeah Peyton Manning would like to thank everyone who supported him in this discussion, but he must concede there's no way he could top Brady now.

 

No.

 

The Pats fans weren't wrong during the rematch where they kept chanting "Brady's better" lol

 

Brady was better a couple Super Bowls ago. This is an old discussion and was over a long time ago.

Great players play Big in Big games......lets keep padding the stats during the season for all its worth.

 

Brady versus Manning...

Cyclical

Montana versus Marino...

History repeats itself.

 

Agree....while I still lean towards Montana as GOAT, I would have to say putting Brady in this position would be legitimately debatable as well. They are in the same room at this point IMO, and I can see the case for both. That said, it is always tough to compare players from different eras.

 

Montana also did it with Rice/Craig/Taylor, etc...IMO, I don't think Brady has receivers quite as good, or at least (A receiver as good as Rice)

 

He had Rice for the last two wins....first two were with Freddie Solomon and Dwight Clark (from "the catch" fame). Brady had Moss and Welker for his 2007 perfect season run, and Dion Branch/David Givens were nothing to sneeze at during their prime IMO.

But yes, as I mentioned, this is perfectly debatable at this point.