I've seen some stupid lists before but this might just take the cake

Agreed but by the same token Young isn't even close to being a backup QB

 

I'd have to actually see Vick play before I deemed him good at anything. Hell for all he know he's just terrible or he could have gotten better who knows. You could do worse as a backup but you could also do a lot better.

I still think Garrard and Schaub are the best backups in the league.

 

I think the reason I give Vick a lot more credit than Vince is because Vick understands what he is. He's an athlete playing QB. Vince doesn't get that. Instead he wants to change people's minds and constantly fails trying to do so.
Plus, lately he doesn't look as if he can even run to make plays anymore.

 

Any post comparing VY with Vick should take into account that Vick is in his 8th year and VY is entering his fourth. Even with the two years he had not played, Vick has more experience than VY.

Beside, is clear that no coach, owner or front office personnel take into account what is written in these forums to reach their decisions. So instead on focusing so much in making sure that some in this thread are right and that VY is a bust, why not hope he becomes a better QB since it will benefit the Titans. We all are at the mercy of the people in charge regarding his future and posting here how good or bad he is has proven beyond the point of reason that those don't like him won't change and those of us who root for will continue to do so why no focus on what matters, the Titans winning.