I've seen some stupid lists before but this might just take the cake

How are fumbles an irrelevant stat?

Vince's main problem: TURNOVERS. So no, it's no an irrelevant stat. Even if it was, Vick is still miles ahead, sadly. And only a Titan fan would argue that.

And don't knock Vick out of the comparison because he hasn't played. Vince hasn't played either, and he has no excuse.

 

Vick was overrated yet people here want to say Vince is better? Vick can't throw but he could run? We're talking about the Vince Young that played in the NFL right? Not the college one.

Vick has at least won a playoff game.

 

He doubled him in TDs and had less ints.

Doubled. He also knows how to use the legs he has and doubled him there too. The only stats vince leads in is by a small margin, there are a few that Vick blows Vince out of the water but not the opposite.

 

Vince doesn't have any wheels though either it seems. Vick has yet to prove if he's still got his.

 

Dude fumbles irrelevant?

Young finds ways to turn the ball over and fumbles are another thing he seriously needs to work on if he's to win back the starting role.

I hope Vick sucks.I think it's shameful that he's been allowed back. Goodell is an inconsistent joke.

 

Vick is a starting QB playing backup at the moment. Those other guys are back ups...being back ups. So yeah, I'd say he's probably one of the best backups. Vince is a 3rd string QB battling for 2nd.