If Fisher returns, who will play QB in 2011?

According to ESPN 360 Arron Rogers says he would like to be a Titan next season if Moss returns.

 

I'd still take VY. VY hasn't reached his full potential. I feel that AR has.

Look what happened to Vick when they tailored a system to him and he was able to get some weapons (DJax, Maclin, Avant).

 

I pray to God KFC is gone. The team can do anything, release Vince, re-sign Nickey for 5 more years, give Chris Hopeless a roster bonus, kick a dog, but please, PLEASE don't re-sign Kerry Collins.

I mean just look at his hands




John Glennon on Twitter said "With Torry Holt unofficially retired, Collins has the most banged-up fingers in football. Both the thumb and middle finger on his right (throwing) hand are injured."

 

Are you saying you'd rather have VY than Aaron Rodgers? You're crazy.

 

Yes I am saying that. No I'm not crazy.

I'll take 2010 Vince over Aaron Rogers. You'll see why in 2011 whether its with us or with another team. He's become a very efficient pocket passer and he still has his mobility. On top of that, he just has that "it" factor.

I'm not saying Rogers isn't a better passer, but Vince is a better package deal.

Would you rather have Vick or Rogers?

 

Obviously Vick. VY isn't Vick though. I'm a big VY supporter.. but if I had the choice between AR or VY, I would take Aaron Rodgers any day of the week.

 

We don't know what Vince can do though because he's been under Fisher his whole career.

Who looked better pre-prison Vick? VY did.

Vick's success this season has a lot to do with him having better weapons and a coach designing their offense around Vick's talents. If we had a coach who could do that with Vince I think Vince would be just as good.

 

They have the QB already. Fisher will ruin any QB we have.

 

Lets take this arguement to the Aaron Rodgers or VY thread.

 

It's Fishers fault, I'm glad VY isn't a p*ssy and just take it over and over from Fish. Go him. Fish is the real diva. I love when they question him about VY. It's obvious that it just irritates the hell out of him. I would have loved to been able to ask him on TV if VY being on the sidelines is what made the team play hard and win last week.