Hester AP "All-Pro" returner- not Pacman

More talented..how?

How do we ascertain that either player is more talented than the other? It's the guy who had the best season.

 

I can't believe we are having this discussion. Hester's average for punt returns was almost identical to Pacman's and they both had 3 TDs.
Hester however also had 2 KO returns for TDs and a FG return for a TD.
It is a no brainer who should be picked as ALL-Pro. Add in that Pac didn't make the Pro-Bowl for the AFC as a returner (got screwed IMO) and it would be very hard to justify being ALL-Pro.