GATFT: George vs. Young

I'm going for loyalty and hope... despite some good memories of Eddie way back there...

 

Eddie. VY hasn't done squat yet...

 

agreed, well he has beaten the cows singlehandedly. But everyone beats the cows

 

VY hasn't done anything yet.

EG

 

winning rookie of the year equals "not doing squat"??? Vince has definatively done "some", in fact hes done a lot for a second year qb.

but anyways, i agree that vince still has a long way to go to catch up to eddie. once vy gets us 1 yard away from a SB overtime... then he'll have my vote

 

I flipped a coin, VY won

 

Eddie by a long shot. Gave his body and soul for this team. To me, Vince still feels like a singular entity as opposed to a Titan. Maybe it'll take time, or just a real show of love and passion for this franchise.
Anyone who feels the need to make reference to Eddie's scamper to Dallas need not, I mean jeez Vince has only been in the league two years, he hasn't had enough time to ditch us like everyone else.

 

eddie for more than just the fact that vy is still new. I miss EG :(

 

I'm a big VY fan, but there are very few players who have given as much as EG did. He was the Titans when McNair was still learning the game. He carried the team on Sundays. He carried the team in practice. No contest for me. In 10 years VY might be close to Eddie but not yet.