In fairness to Alex Smith, it has only been one year..The way you put it I guess it would have been a waste of time to play T.Aikman, and P.Manning their second years. I believe VY should start. The key is having the maturity to handle disappointment and learn from it. Also to show improvement. The Green Bay game showed me that VY has what it takes. VY looked tons better to me then A.Rodgers, and Rodgers is in his second year. Some have it...Some don't. That being said VY will probably not start. But I will say this. If VY makes things happen everytime he is in the game he WILL be starting very soon.