Does Steve McNair deserve to be a Hall Of Famer?

Discussion in 'Tennessee Titans and NFL Talk' started by Titanic12th, Apr 12, 2014.

  1. Titanic12th

    Titanic12th Starter

    108
    60
    134
    According to Paul Kuharsky not only does he feel like he doesn't deserve to be in, he says he isn't even close to being a great player of his generation. Thoughts?
    #1
  2. Scarecrow

    Scarecrow CEO of PPO Tip Jar Donor

    24,530
    12,095
    989
    Wrong sub forum and if you are going to say 'According to Paul Kuharsky', it helps to provide the link with that quote, so posters have something to reference.

    This is how a good thread is started, not trying to be a dick.
    #2
  3. Titanic12th

    Titanic12th Starter

    108
    60
    134
    Understood. Never posted on here before. It's on ESPN.COM. I can try to get the link
    #3
  4. Scarecrow

    Scarecrow CEO of PPO Tip Jar Donor

    24,530
    12,095
    989
    #4
  5. Titanic12th

    Titanic12th Starter

    108
    60
    134
    Yeah that's it...straight b.s.
    #5
  6. SawdustMan

    SawdustMan Stronger than Justin Hunter Tip Jar Donor

    14,739
    8,715
    709
    I'm with Paul on this.

    I loved Steve just like everyone else. But somewhere along the way many, many Titan fans seem to have put Steve on this pedestal that he really doesn't deserve to be on, at least IMO. Is he the greatest Titan QB ever? Absolutely. Is that really saying much? Not really.
    #6
    • High Five High Five x 7
  7. RavensShallBurn

    RavensShallBurn Ruck the Favens

    22,768
    9,487
    939
    I used to say he would make it in eventually.

    Then I took the homer glasses off and realized it's just not going to happen.

    Eddie and Mase both have a better chance at making it in. Mase is around top 10 all time for receiving yards. Somewhere in that range. Eddie is in the 10,000+ rush yard club, which is a pretty solid one.

    Steve was just a warrior and only had a couple of elite seasons. Average or mediocre the rest of his career. But he's still my favorite player. He gave it his all every Sunday.
    #7
    • High Five High Five x 1
  8. SawdustMan

    SawdustMan Stronger than Justin Hunter Tip Jar Donor

    14,739
    8,715
    709
    Yeah I think it's the whole "warrior" aspect combined with his tragic death that explains a lot of the overhyping of Steve's place in history. Loved the guy. Respect the hell out of his toughness. But he's not a HoFer.
    #8
  9. Scarecrow

    Scarecrow CEO of PPO Tip Jar Donor

    24,530
    12,095
    989
    If you have to ask.......then they don't deserve it.
    #9
  10. nickmsmith

    nickmsmith Most poverty RB core.

    11,687
    5,231
    669
    No. His career didnt earn him a spot there, and his controversial cheating death sealed the deal.
    #10