No because faulk bobbled the ball initially. those who say they should have gone to welcher the answer is they did on the previous play but powers jumped the route and knocked the ball away. I agree a dumb call but if a team was going to go for a 4th and 2 in that spot they were as good as any. Faulk and welcher are among the best in the league for getting that first down and brady is a hall of fame bound QB. Personally i would never have done it as a coach because i wouldn't want the blame that would come if unsuccessful but a coach with 4 super bowl appearences and 3 wins maybe is beyond that concern.