Arbitrator Rules for McNair

You're batting 0% Mac will have one of his best years no matter where he plays. It's wishful thinking that the Ratbird's will be awefull. They have two quality backs three good receivers a strong defense and a top 5 QB. The cowboys will by no means win the superbowl out of the NFC Carolina and the Redskins are the teams to watch.

Baltimore are too old.

1. no I'm not.

2. no it isn't

3. so what?

4. we'll see...

If McNair shows up at a Raven facility there will be issues. Aside from "mental" training, he can't be at a Raven facility or practice with any Raven players while he's still under contract with the Titans.

When where and how would the Ravens have a top 5 QB? Where did that come from? If you mean McNair, maybe you'll try to justify it that he was in the pro bowl. Well, that's top 6, and he only got there because of two others ahead of him backing out. Also, NONE of his stats are in the top 5, most aren't close to the top ten.

I've loved mac, but the more I'm thinking about it, he's not who he was, and isn't likely to have another great comeback year.

I'm in the camp that thinks Mac will be a disappointment for the Ravens. Mac cannot run like he used to so a big part of his game is gone. Mac is injury prone and if he was a RB instead of a QB he would rank right there with Chris Brown in durability. At his age and talent level those injuries have a much more drastic effect on his play. Look at all the games Mac missed or played in where he wasn't 100% the last two years (almost everyone). Mac is going to a new city with new coaches, players and a new offensive system. That will effect his play more than most think.
Finally, the Raven fans and FO expect more than Mac can deliver and even if Mac has a decent year if he isn't back to his 2004 level they will be disappointed.