Discussion in 'Tennessee Titans and NFL Talk' started by TitanJeff, Jun 6, 2008.
Excellent idea let's go to Smack.
well sir i havent been talking smack
just trying to talk some football
So you don't know what your saying? Typical dolt...
Your only talking about the Colts!
again you just cant stick with the conversation can you
don't you have someone else to irritate
Oh that's rich! Coming from a colt flamer who wants to start a conversation about Manning vs McNair MVP in a thread about 2008 QB's...
Cooley has more tds and more yards in one less year. You saying he's better than shockey shows your homerism. And do you think clark is a great blocking te? He lines up out wide half the time.
Wait, you do realize Crumpler has played 7 seasons and Clark has played 5? Clark is 1978 yards behind Crumpler. Do you think Clark is fixing to have back-to-back 1000 yard seasons?? Not my fault if he couldn't get the start, or was injured. That is part of comparing a career.
Both are consistent. Clark will have to tie his second best TD season for two seasons in a row to MATCH crumpler. Clark has just had one monster season receiving TDs, will it really continue?
Here's something interesting, how many 20+yard catches has Clark had in his best season? 8. Crumpler more than doubled that in his best season, and posted 3 seasons with 10+ catches for 20+yards. Crumpler leads that race 68 to 31. Will clark have 19 or more 20+yards catches in BACK TO BACK seasons to be ahead of Crumpler at equal points in the career?? No.
I see what TJ is saying, that crumpler could be done if his knees are horrible. I'm assuming they aren't.
Bottom Line 1: Crumpler has the better career over Clark. And he's done it with a worse team. Crumpler is better.
Bottom Line 2: Crumpler/Scaife/C.Stevens is easily the squad I would prefer over Clark/Tamme. I mean Stevens was drafted before Tamme. And he's our 3rd TE!
The Titans have superior TEs.
I'd rank Clark over everyone except Gates and Whitten before we draft for Titan Cup next season.
Separate names with a comma.