If the author-fan in BR is impressed with Mcnair's career 83 passing rating what about Phillip Rivers and Tony Romo's 95? So i can say that Romo with his 95 career rating is better than Elway or Marino then? Chad Pennington has a career rating of 90. Hall of fame material? In the 93 year history of the nfl there are 23 modern era Qbs in the HOF. Mcnair was not that elite!