I've seen some stupid lists before but this might just take the cake

I don't disagree with it that much. Vick is much too high yes and I might rearrange a few but it's not that stupid.

 

its pretty stupid. Vince Young should be above Michael Vick. Yes, VY is a backup. How is our Third String QB from last year making the list, and our current backup not even on the list?

 

At least they have number 1 right!

Jeff Garcia, from my home town, the GARLIC capital of the WORLD!

GOOOOOOO Garlic! I mean, GARCIA!!!!! :jump:

 

Young is on the list (21) and Simms could actually start at some point

liked this pic, so I post it

 

I like #'s 21 - 32 more than 11 - 20

 

"Young has made some decent strides this preseason, but the fact that he's trying to hold off veteran Patrick Ramsey at No. 2 rather than battling Kerry Collins for the No. 1 job is all you need to know about where his stock resides in Tennessee as his make-or-break fourth NFL season dawns."

The SI writer is a Hater, obviously.

 

Yea, this list is out of whack. I'd put Young higher, and Vick lower.

 

Fixed.

 

If you base it on Vicks previos play he should be right where he is. We are talking #2's ... he was an NFL QB with multiple playoff appearances. Young should be a little higher but most of the rest of it I agree with.