Where does Vince rank among playoff QB's?

1. P. Manning
2. Brady
3. Favre
4. Romo
5. Big Ben
6. Garrard
7. Hasslebeck
8. Rivers
9. E. Manning
10. Garcia
11. Young
12. Collins

In terms of Running VY obviously is head and shoulders above those QB's except Garrard who is decent but no VY.

In terms of passing all of those QB's even Collins is above VY. Sorry but it's the truth he has a long way to go and hopefully he gets there.

If were talking about leadership and enthusiasm VY is at the top with Favre and Romo but I didn't see it as much this year as I did last year so hopefully he comes back rejuvenated and and a better passer next year which I think he will.

 

I think Eli Manning should be ranked higher after tonight. Giants 21, Cowboys 17.

 

Eli is proving everyone wrong. I still have my doubts, but damn, AFC championship. Tiki is hiding.

 

Rivers & Eli really stepped it up but Rivers.Man what an butthole

 

Lets look at these QB's weapons why dont we while we are at it....

Manning = Wayne, Clark, Addia, Harrison, Gonzalez

Favre= Driver, Jennings, Robinson, Grant, Lee

Brady= Moss, Welker, Watson, Stallworth, Maroney (please no more )

Eli Manning = Toomer, Plax, Jacobs, Shockey, Moss

Romo = T.O., Crayton, Glenn, Jjones, Barber, Witten

Hasselback= Branch, Hackett, Burlenson, Engram, Alexander

Big Ben = Ward, Miller, Holmes, Parker, Davenport

Campbell= moss, randel el, cooley, portis, mccardell

Rivers = LT!!!!, Chambers, Jackson, Turner, Gates

Garcia = Gallaway, Clayton, Engram, Cadalac, (ehhhhh)

Garrard= MJDrew, Taylor, Mercedez, Wilford, williams, jones

Young= Scaife, RWilliams, Gage, LW, Moulds,

So you rank QB's from who they are as a individual player
Brady, Manning, Favre, Romo, Hasselback, Big Ben, Garrard, Garcia, Eli, Young, Rivers, Campbell.

How about ranking with weapons
Brady, Manning, Romo, Rivers, Big Ben, Favre, Eli, Hasselback, Garrard, Campbell, Garcia, Young.

The point being that even though Young might not be at the top of the list, look at teh guys who are, and their weapons as well. Young basically went into the playoffs a one man show, with a decent runnning attack.

 

I think it was a great pick because now it forces fisher to change his ways. All of us here have wanted him to go to a more modern offense for years now he has to or he'll more than likely never get to super bowl level. I would agree if they don't start bringing in skill players and don't switch up the offensive mentality it could have been a mistake.

 

so, it is the supporting cast that makes the QB. Not the OB that makes the supporting cast.

Which came first? The chicken or the egg.

 

How many of those guys would you have ranked ahead of VY at 24, or after 27 career starts?

Patience is a virtue...