Fred Taylor...

I think if Jacksonville would have been in the NFC where Fragile Fred only played the Titans every 4 years then you might have something to argue about. But I am not certain FT ever finished a game against the Titans so based on what I saw he was not at all impressive

 

He was probably the most underrated player in the NFL during his era.

Ray Lewis said he was the best RB in the league.

 

Went to UF and played for the Jags. What is there to like about him?

 

Even Domanick Davis/Williams had his couple years in the sun at the same time. Taylor was traded for Jones-Drew who I also think in the big scheme of RB may be underrated but due to the "magic age of 30" and the cost, his career was shorter than some of the greats.
Fred Taylor was excellent and we could argue Bo Jackson as one of the greatest if not for his injury as well, although a much smaller sample size, but that's the way history is. Injuries get no free pass on the list of greats. Could say the same for Gale Sayers (and some do)

I didn't mean physical trade between Taylor and Jones-Drew before anyone misunderstands that.

 

Health is part of the game.

Personally, my most under-rated is Curtis Martin.

 

He was decent from what I remember...but as others said, I remember him being hurt quite a bit. Nothing special ifirk

 

orrrr if barry sanders didnt retire early he would be the greatest.